Suite Francaise and the Question No One Can Answer in Time

December 31, 2025

I’ve just finished listening to Suite Francaise by Irene Nemirovsky, a novel written during the early years of World War II and left unfinished when the author was arrested and later killed at Auschwitz. The history of the book gives it added weight because it was written during the actual period, yet the most striking thing to me wasn’t the tragedy, but the ordinariness.

This book is not really about heroes or villains in the usual sense. It is a book about people cooking meals, worrying about money, caring for the children, negotiating with neighbors, and trying to remain themselves while history presses in from every side.

As I listened, one question kept returning:

Is there a moment when it becomes wiser to leave than to stay?

Is it a clear decision, an act of agency, to choose to become a refugee? Suite Francaise shows us that people rarely know when the turning point has arrived. They act on rumors, half-truths, fear, hope, and attachment. They choose with children watching, with elderly parents who cannot walk very far, and with the belief that this situation cannot possibly last.

Some flee. Some Stay.

None of them escape lass.

The novel makes it clear that there is no moral high ground here. Leaving may preserve life but fracture identity. Staying may preserve dignity but risk destruction. Courage exists on both sides, and so does regret.

Reading this now, from a safe distance in time and space, I’m aware of how easy it is to judge these decisions with the advantage of hindsight. But the people living inside the moment do not have that luxury. They cannot see the ending. They only know what is bearable and what is not.

Perhaps the most honest truth from the book:

Becoming a refugee is rarely a choice; it is the least unbearable option among unbearable ones.

Perhaps refuge itself is not the destination. Maybe it is the act of choosing what you can live with becoming.

If you are curious about this book

Suite Francaise is reflective, humane, and unsentimental. It doesn’t tell you what to think; but it asks you to notice. If you enjoy literature that explores moral ambiguity, resilience, and the interior lives of ordinary people during extraordinary times, it is well worth reading or listening to.

Still Curious. Still Growing, Still Grateful.

by Janis @ Simple Raw and Natural

Comments

Happy in the Garden

Yesterday I worked in the garden instead of walking around the neighborhood. It is a different feeling. It's true that I only got in about 6500 steps by the end of the day instead of over 10,000, but it was a different feeling. Travis planted some tomatoes and peppers, I cleaned the lower deck and pulled some weeds. Lucy dug in the dirt and felt so happy. I felt the same way. Working in the garden makes you feel happy and productive. I was puzzled by a plant growing in the herb garden as a weed. I started pulling them out but decided to check if they are edible. Edible weeds, such as dandelion, can be used in our smoothies. I put a picture on Facebook to ask for help identifying the weed, and the consensus is that it is plantain. Some say edible and some say not, but I am inclined to think that it is edible. My brother, Max, lives up in the mountains, and his neighbor says it is edible and the smallest leaves are best with...

The Lou Corona Story

Yesterday, we went to Magic Springs with our daughter, son-in-law and three grandchildren. The landscaping there is beautiful this year. This one little flower didn't let a little concrete stop it. Lunch today was three bananas which I ate about 1:30. I'm letting my body rest a little bit after eating too much food the last couple of days. I did domestic chores today. But Travis made a trip to the City Compost Facility for another load of compost. We'll use it on the trees we still have left to plant. We have a volunteer tomato plant coming up in one of the garden beds. It's doing pretty well, too. I have it on my to do list to buy some more tomato cages. The arugula I planted is up. The kale Travis planted is up. The new plum tree is planted. Here is a volunteer Poke Salat that came with the blueberry plant. Travis planted some more blueberries in the blueberry row that lines our driveway. The...

Alko Shredder

It was chilly this morning, but I got out and worked a bit in the garden bed that had the strawberries moved out yesterday. I fed it with the mineral supplement and fertilizer. I started putting on compost, but ran out of time before I finished. We are going to plant some kale in this bed. Bed #3 weeded, minerals added, fertilized, and partly composted. Travis and I went to an estate sale today. First thing we saw was a garden shredder. We bought it for $60.00 and brought it home. There are lots of leaves in my yard that could be shredded. Our new used Alko shredder...made in Germany. For dinner tonight I made a soup. The inspiration came from Dara Dubinet on her You-tube video, but mine was different because I used what we had. My vegetable soup recipe: Juice a beet, 6 carrots, 3 broccoli stalks, and a sweet potato. Then heat a pot of water on the stove, but do not boil. In the Vita-Mix, put 3 med...

Simple Raw and Natural

Search This Blog